Your Ad Here
Results 1 to 4 of 4

Thread: PTSD Rewrite

  1. #1
    Scribe Lester Burnham's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Posts
    83

    PTSD Rewrite

    Amy sat across from me in one of the two Queen Anns. She looked vacantly at the floor and her shoulders slumped downward, as if ready to collapse under the weight of a hard life. She used a pale finger to absently toy with a strand of hair that hung by her cheek and was silent save the sound of her breathing. She was the third of four assessments I would do that day. Clients came in waves in residential treatment and that day I was surfing.

    I had read her intake notes, a page of dispassionate scrawls from the admissions nurse, and was already writing the psychosocial in my head before I asked her any questions.

    22 year old white female, complaint of cocaine dependence. Patient admits to alcohol and poly-substance abuse since age 11. Began using intranasal powder cocaine 3 years ago and has been using I.V. intermittently for the past six months in amounts averaging from 1-2 grams daily while binging.

    I didn’t need the chart to tell me she had likely been supporting her habit with dancing or hooking or both. It came with the territory.

    She was a pretty girl. Even with the dark bags under her eyes that looked like bruises against her wan skin, and the track marks in the soft tissue at the bend of each arm, she had a beauty that almost overshadowed the ravages of her addiction.

    Almost.

    She shivered, but remained silent. I went to a linen closet and got her a blanket. She wrapped herself in it without speaking.

    I would get past the preliminaries with her as quickly as possible. Like all addicts, she had a story that went past her drug use. That story was my job. The rest, the drugs she used, how much and when and for how long was just the requirements for documentation; an insurance matter. But it was something that had to be attended to.

    I wish I could tell you that my work is like breaking a great and mystical code; that it requires a combination of high intellect and finely honed skills. I can’t though. One look at her and most people would have a pretty good idea what the story was. Something, somewhere in her life had caused her enough pain, enough trauma, that she would stick needles in her arm to keep from thinking about it. Something, likely someone, had robbed her of enough self worth that she could smile while crawling naked on a dirty floor, scraping up the money for her habit from a crowd of drunken lechers. The only trick was getting her to talk about it.

    I would do that. I had my ways. But I still had no assurances it would help. Addictions have no memory. They move forward of their own volition, by their own will. But when repressing the trauma is killing you, the only thing that makes sense is to get it out; to face the demons and talk them down. It's not a cure, but it's a chance.

    And talk she eventually did, though it didn’t come easy. She sat through most groups as though cloaked in a shadow, responding to queries with short, sometimes monosyllabic answers designed more to fend off other questions than to give up information. In her individual sessions she would talk a bit more, focusing mostly on her drug use, but quickly withdrew when I nudged the conversation a little deeper.

    At two weeks into her treatment, and more importantly with only two weeks remaining, I tossed in the towel on tact and strategy and asked her the question.

    “Amy, did someone sexually abuse you?”

    It was the most animated I ever saw her. Her eyes went wide in surprise. Her mouth opened and froze in place. Her skin color, which she had regained with two weeks of abstinence and regular meals, drained from her face and was replaced by a bloody flush. Tears pooled and teetered on her lower eyelids, but didn’t fall.

    “Can you talk about it?”

    She shook her head slightly.

    I waited a moment, then leaned forward and spoke to her as softly as possible.

    “I understand,” I said. “But I want you to consider putting it on paper. You don’t even need to show it to me. You may find at some point you want to show it to someone. And maybe whoever you show it to can help you understand that it wasn’t your fault.”

    I let her go early from the session and called the nursing station to have her put on close observation. Tapping in to peoples pain sometimes has tragic results.

    When I got to work the next morning I found a blue folder that had been slid under my door. It was Amy’s story, in Amy’s words, and each page I turned cut through me like hot knife.

    It was her father.

    He started touching her at age six. That progressed to other things as he continued grooming her; using her.

    And along the way he taught her, in his own way, what all fathers are supposed to teach. Her worth as a person.

    For him, her hand was worth five dollars. Her mouth twice that much, even more if she “finished.” Other parts of her body had their value, too. And he paid for, owned, all of them.

    For ten years.

    He trained her well enough. Eventually, when she wanted money or other things, she came to him. She would tell me later that it made her feel special, even powerful.

    But that illusion of power eventually played it’s way out, and you could see the results all over her life and all over her body. Every degradation she ever suffered had traveled through a spike and up her arms. Every violation a prescription for hopelessness. Humiliation and abuse became a deviated septum and hepatitis C; Every needle mark a thousand unshed tears.

    That power? It had lead her, no, drug her, to my office, unable to look me in the eye or even to tell someone, anyone, that she was cold. And it forced me to do something that I am not supposed to as a professional.

    Care.

    The one necessity of my work is detachment. You get too close, too involved, you are helping no one, and you run the danger of causing harm. Anyone in this field will tell you that the ground rules mean doing the best you can and letting go of the results. That was no longer an option for me. I wanted Amy to make it.

    I passed her in the hall a couple of days before she discharged. She was sitting on the floor with her back to the wall. An assortment of family photographs was scattered across the tiles at her feet. She was sifting through that collection of memories as though it were a puzzle. Her face was cheerless, even more than usual, and her fingers trembled as she stopped to take a longer look at a particular picture.

    “You O.K.?” I asked.

    She looked up and seemed to notice me for the first time. She hesitated, then tilted her head to the side in an invitation to sit with her. It was the most intimate gesture she’d made to me since her arrival.

    I took a spot on the floor next to her and looked at the picture. It was her at about eight or nine years old. The camera had caught her in a smile, but she carried a sadness in her eyes that remained with her till that day. I started to say something, then remembered that one of my most valuable tools was knowing when to keep my mouth shut. I just sat with her, joining her in her silence and we studied her picture together. After a few moments she cleared her throat and spoke.

    “I used to love horses,” she said. “I used to day dream that like a prince or something would come and take me away on a horse and I would be happy and safe my whole life.”

    A tear fell down her cheek and she laid the picture down on the floor. She rubbed her eyes and tried to offer a half-hearted smile, one of Amy‘s sure signs she didn‘t want to talk.

    I spotted a tablet on the floor. ‘Amy’s Artwork’ was written calligraphy style across the cover. I pointed at it and asked, “Do you mind?”

    “Sure, I used to draw, some.” she said, her tone confirming her mind was elsewhere.

    I opened the tablet and my first reaction was simply being impressed. But as I turned the pages my reaction went from just impressed to startled, then disbelief, then complete awe.

    The subjects of her drawing were people. Not just faces and features, but emotions and states of mind. She went far beyond the simpler interpretations of anger, sadness and joy. She drew curiosity into the eyes of a child, contemplation in an old woman; brief hesitance in the expression of a man; and of course, despair in a young girl. She drew the depth and subtlety of human emotion with the deftness and clarity of a great master.

    In her work, done with merely pencil and paper, she demonstrated more understanding of the human soul than most therapists. Each page I turned was another awakening, another breathtaking revelation of the genius that sat next to me. Suddenly, I felt as humbled and inept as I ever have in my life. I reached up and wiped my eye, then looked at the tip of my finger, now moist with one of my own tears.

    Two months after she left treatment, a month after her father began serving time, I got the call that she was dead. It was an overdose, of course. They found her splayed out next to a dumpster. Whoever she was using with just dumped her onto the pavement amid the garbage to avoid problems with the law.

    I’m sure the coroner's report gave drug overdose as the cause of death. But that was just the interpretation of cold science. The coroner no more knew what caused her death than I knew how to help her live. What I do know is this: Amy's death was a homicide. Her father murdered her when she was six years old.

    It just took her 16 years to figure it out.
    Last edited by Lester Burnham; 03-28-2009 at 08:50 PM.
    Suppose they had a gender war and men showed up?

    http://www.avoiceformen.com

  2. #2
    silverwriter
    Guest
    Hello again!

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    She used a pale finger to absently toy with a strand of hair that hung by her cheek


    I'm really not trying to be rude, but this gave me a bit of a chuckle. I just pictured a pale, skinny girl using someone's pale, dead finger to play with her hair.

    Perhaps something like, "She absently toyed with a strand of her hair with her pale fingers..."

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    Clients came in waves in residential treatment and that day I was surfing.


    I like this line.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    I had read her intake notes, a page of dispassionate scrawls from the admissions nurse


    I quite like this as well. 'Dispassionate scrawls' paints a picture of an overworked admissions nurse who has started to become numb to at all. At least, that's what I imagine. Either way, it paints a good picture.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    how much and when and for how long was just the requirements for documentation; an insurance matter.


    Feel free to disagree with me on this because I'm not exactly an authority, but I believe the semi-colon shouldn't be used here. When you use a semi-colon, both parts should be complete sentences. I think "requirements for documentation - an insurance matter" would work better.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    I wish I could tell you that my work is like breaking a great and mystical code; that it requires a combination of high intellect and finely honed skills.


    This is another for the semi-colon. I think a comma would work fine here.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    Something, somewhere in her life had caused her enough


    I've been looking at this for a few minutes now, going back and forth... I do think you should take out that comma. The urge is to put it there because 'something' and 'somewhere' are so similar, but it actually isn't needed in my opinion.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    I would do that. I had my ways.


    This is just complete opinion, but even writing in past tense, you can use the occasional present tense. "I had my ways" makes me wonder - albeit briefly - if the narrator is dead or just out of the business. If s/he is, okay. If not, "I have my ways" works. You're still telling the story of a past patient - thus the past tense - but if the narrator is still doing that job, the present tense 'have' works.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    But when repressing the trauma is killing you, the only thing that makes sense is to get it out; to face the demons and talk them down.


    Another semi-colon that I think would suit find as a comma. I need to break out my Strunk and White to make sure I'm on the right track with this one.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    when I nudged the conversation a little deeper.


    I think it sounds 'tighter' if you take out 'a little'. That's just a matter of preference, though.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    At two weeks into her treatment


    So, is this two weeks after where this begins? Or has it been two weeks, the narrator was musing a bit, and now we're back to the beginning where she's sitting across from the narrator and s/he has given the girl a blanket?

    That's not quite clear here. A connection back to the beginning would be good. For instance: "Now, at two weeks into her treatment, as she sat across from me playing with her hair..." That would be a bad way to write it, but you see what I mean? You've let us wander with the narrator to get her background; now reel us back in with the landmarks you've set up.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    It was the most animated I ever saw her.


    A general rule of thumb I learned when just getting into writing is that you should try to avoid starting sentences with 'it'. You can take a version of this sentence and put it after her actions. The sentence still works with that placement.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    Her eyes went wide in surprise. Her mouth opened and froze in place. Her skin color, which she had regained with two weeks of abstinence and regular meals, drained from her face and was replaced by a bloody flush.


    Her, her, her. Try switching up the sentence structure a bit.

    And see, here is where I am confused again. I was almost certain that we were back to the 'current' scene - as in, back to the beginning where she is sitting across from the narrator, pale and such. But now she has regained her colour and is no longer pale. Hrm. Oops on might part.

    With this being two weeks later from the beginning, I'm left wondering why we had the detail at all of her sitting there. She's sitting there. The narrator is taking notes and his/her mind wanders. Now it's two weeks later and nothing (that is written) actually happened while she was sitting there and the narrator was thinking.

    The timing needs some clarity, which I think could be achieved by little things like adding “two weeks into her treatment, the pale, shivering girl had begun to disappear”. Just so we get some closure on the scene you opened with.

    Am I being at all clear in this? I have this bad feeling that I'm not…

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    Tears pooled and teetered on her lower eyelids, but didn’t fall.


    No comma needed.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    I waited a moment, then leaned forward and spoke to her as softly as possible.

    “I understand,” I said. “But I want you to consider putting it on paper....


    This works as one paragraph.

    "I waited a moment, then leaned forward and spoke to her as softly as possible. “I understand. But I want you to consider putting it on paper..."

    This also works as two paragraphs, but what I'm trying to say is that you don't need the second, I said. You've already established who is going to be talking next.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    It was her father.
    I think just ‘her father’ would be more powerful, and it would take away the ‘it’ beginning.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    For ten years.
    I can’t believe I’m saying this (and am wondering why I didn’t catch it before), but she’s twenty-two and he used her for ten years? That would have made her twelve when he started. Isn’t that a little… late?

    Of course, being in nonfiction, I probably shouldn’t say anything, should I? A case is a case. People do weird things. I just thought, in general, pedophiles started grooming the children at a younger age.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    But that illusion of power eventually played it’s way out


    Its

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    That power? It had lead her, no, drug her, to my office, unable to look me in the eye or even to tell someone, anyone, that she was cold.


    Because of the nature of this piece and the subject matter, perhaps ‘forced’ instead of ‘drug’ would be better wording.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    And it forced me to do something that I am not supposed to as a professional.

    Care.


    These two sentences that rub me the wrong way. They seem a bit cardboard, I guess… Instead of being told, I would like to read something like how angry Amy’s past made the narrator feel or how Amy’s case was one of the worst ones the narrator had seen in a long time and that made him/her angry… Perhaps the narrator sees something in this young woman that reminds him/her of him/herself.

    I want to be shown that the narrator was forced to care more than told.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    I passed her in the hall a couple of days before she discharged.


    That sentence seems to be missing a word… How about before she ‘got’ discharged or before she ‘was’ discharged?

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    She was sifting


    She shifted

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    “You O.K.?” I asked.


    The abbreviation is fine (I think), but I think ‘okay’ just looks much better.

    [quote=Lester Burnham;1256066]

    She looked up and seemed to notice me for the first time. She hesitated, then tilted her head to the side in an invitation to sit with her. It was the most intimate gesture she’d made to me since her arrival.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    It was her at about eight or nine years old. The camera had caught her in a smile, but she carried a sadness in her eyes that remained with her till that day.


    Why is she sad at eight or nine if her father wasn’t messing with her until she was twelve?

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    one of Amy‘s sure signs she didn‘t want to talk.


    We know who is there. “one of her sure signs” works.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    “Sure, I used to draw, some[,]” she said, her tone confirming her mind was elsewhere.


    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    [A]
    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    s I turned the pages my reaction went from just impressed to startled, then disbelief, then complete awe.


    This reads as a bit awkward to me. Putting such strong emotions into a basic list-type form takes away some of the power of it.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    The subjects of her drawing[s] were people.


    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    Not just faces and features, but emotions and states of mind.


    No comma needed. It’s also a fragment and could be combined with the previous sentence, but I won’t get that picky.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    She drew curiosity into the eyes of a child, contemplation in an old woman; brief hesitance in the expression of a man; and of course, despair in a young girl.


    Put in commas instead of semicolons.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    I reached up and wiped my eye, then looked at the tip of my finger, now moist with one of my own tears.

    Two months after she left treatment, a month after her father began serving time, I got the call that she was dead.


    That’s very dramatic and abrupt. Did the narrator try to check in with her, seeing as Amy caused the narrator to care? Did the narrator try to keep tabs on her somehow?

    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    [She died of] an overdose, of course.


    Quote Originally Posted by Lester Burnham View Post
    It just took her [sixteen] years to figure it out.


    I very much like what you’ve done with this piece (even though I dismantled this version a bit as well). I feel more connected to a life (and, in this version, a talent) completely wasted by abuse and a rotten life. I have an easier time in this version identifying with Amy as a human instead of a statistic.

    I’d like to see just a pinch more pushing about her father and what he did to her. Maybe even just a picture of him that she rips up or something to remind us before the end of the ‘bad guy’ in this tragedy.

    With the timing thing: I’ve thought more about it and I think it just comes down to there being no real ‘conclusion’ to that first bit. She’s sitting there, the narrator is sitting there… and suddenly it is two weeks later. Have the narrator start the interview … ‘two weeks later’. Of have the narrator dismiss her to check into her room … ‘two weeks later’.

    I hope that makes more sense than my previous ramblings.
    Last edited by silverwriter; 03-30-2009 at 12:08 PM.

  3. #3
    Scribe Lester Burnham's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Posts
    83
    If you want a job as my editor, please let me know, lol! Thanks again for all the insight and thoughfulness.

    I did struggle quite a bit about digging more into her father. My concern was that I wanted the reader to focus on her and not him. Anger at this type of bastard is a given, and once triggered it is all some people can think about.

    Also, in the part where we looked at her pictures together, she didn't tear up a picture of her father. I think I could add that and still call it non-fiction, but to honor Amy I have really tried to write this as it happened as much as possible.

    Thanks again for your help.
    Suppose they had a gender war and men showed up?

    http://www.avoiceformen.com

  4. #4
    silverwriter
    Guest
    Haha. And here I was thinking you were going to regret having me take a look at the rewrite.

    Yes, I understand it is quite a difficult balance to make sure we focus on the bright, lovely young woman instead of the man who ruined her life. Still, you don't want the reader to forget about him completely.

    Of course, you're completely right about staying true to what actually happened. I'm just plain not used to critiquing non-fiction is the problem. Definitely stay true to what actually happened and ignore my occasional memory lapses where I think I'm back in fiction land.

    Cheers.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •