Not too bad so far. Several choppy and confusing sentences, mis-placed commas, and other mis-used words. Also, I had trouble with the narrator. Almost the entire story is being told by the prisoner, but then the narrator will say something that I'm not sure the prisoner would say. You can fix this 2 ways:
1.) Read back through the story and look at everything the narrator says. Rework any info-dump segments into speech that is short and to the point. Make all the narration tighter, more concise.
2.) Separate the narrator and the main character. Any thought from the main character can be changed to italics to indicate thought. This way might be easier becasue you can have your narrator relay information to the reader without it sounded misplaced by having the prisoner say it. I'll show you some examples later in the critique of what I mean by the narrator saying odd things.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
Background info: This story takes place in the distant future, the prisons are over filling and the government decides to empty out all their prisons, and put the prisoners on a hell world.
|
I think
over-flowing would be a better word choice. And what exactly is a "hell world"? If it's not something specific you have in mind, then I would change it to "a desolate world" or something to that effect. If it is some place you've created, maybe capitalize to make it a proper place.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
I stared at the glop on my tray. It stared back at me; a slimy yellow grin almost seemed to be visible in its viscosity.
|
Good couple of sentences. I like the visual.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
The prison had downgraded the food again to save money, too little money - too many prisoners.
|
This sentence is a tad clunky. I understand what you're trying to say, but it's not down very effectively. The "too little money" refers to the fact that even though the food is downgraded again, it doesn't really save enough money and maybe that's because they're are so many prisoners. At least I think that's what you're getting at. If so, even though I got it, it's still confusing. Look that sentence over a bit.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
I had just come back from a 3-year trip to solitary confinement.
|
I don't know much about prison and what-not, but isn't 3 years a bit much for SC? From what I know of, SC is being shoved in a tiny, lightless living space. I know that in movies (The Great Escape), they spend maybe a week or two at the most. But then again, this is the future, so maybe in your continuity 3 years is normal. Just something to think about.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
The moral of that story: If one of your fellow inmates pisses you off, make sure no one’s around to see you beat him into a coma.
|
Okay, here we have something that is obviously said by the prisoner, but in narrator fashion because he refers to the "story", but the next few sentences...
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
The cafeteria hadn’t changed much, except for a fresh coat of white paint, which was quickly reverting to its original brown color. It was still the ridiculously huge room it had always been, but then again this was the biggest prison around. Unfortunately for security, this made it next to impossible to stop things before they started.
|
This is all info-dump about the prison. I think that the two comments are inconsistent of the narrator. Now, if you broke these two sections up, one by the prisoner, one by the narrator, I think it would help it to flow a lot easier.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
Too few guards, too little money, too many prisoners.
|
This is almost an indentical repeat of the "too little..." part from above, but it doesn't repeat anymore in the story which makes the repetition seem like a mistake. If you plan on using it, make it consistent. Have the narrator/prisoner keep noticing things that there are "too little..." of.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
Four years back some 1-doofus tried to tell me that they were gonna execute all of us to make room for more, never happened. Though really it wouldn’t surprise me, the system is 2-so fucking corrupt: 3-The white collar criminals who steal billions get away with about ten years maximum; while the guy who robs the grocery store with a toy gun to feed his family gets about twenty.
|
Alright, there are several things wrong with this paragraph:
1 - "doofus" doesn't sound like an insult that the hardened gang member, who is apparently of asian decent, would normally use. "doofus" is an old word, not something you hear too often, so I doubt the word would be very popular in the future. When writing your characters, you have to know them, know what they'll say in what situations, what they'll think of people. The only way you can make your characters likeable and realisitc is to keep them consistent.
2. - Using curse words in writing is a tough thing to judge. I find that most people use them for shock value and just because they can, but I think that it has a negative effect on writing. It dumbs down what the writing is trying to say because all the focus is on the curse word. "Oh man, he just said 'fuck'! I'm not sure what about, but he said it!", that kind of thing. Be very careful when using curse words. And also, as a narrator, its not necessary to use curse words. Usually only in dialouge can it be more easily justified.
3. - This is just a personal comment, but I think this part is a bit hackneyed. The corporate men with money getting let off while the little man takes the fall, that sorta thing. Maybe explore something else that might make the system corrupt.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
I glanced down when I heard some snickering, I turned to see an old man walking down the aisle, and damn, was he old.
|
This is another example of the narrator thing. See if this makes more sense of what I'm saying:
Matsuda glanced down the aisle as he heard a man snickering.
Damn, he's old, he thought to himself.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
He had a white beard that 1-hanged down to his chest, and his bald head was splotchier than what the prison menu claimed was mashed potatoes and gravy. He was so thin that it looked like if one of the prisoners 2-farted with enough force, they would send him flying. The green and yellow slime on his tray jiggled obscenely from his arms shaking so much; it seemed like every step he took he had stolen from the bony fingers of death. 3-No man deserved to live so long that they looked like a walking corpse. Yet at the same time, I couldn’t help but notice a gleam in his eyes, something that told me that there was more to this zombie then most would see at first glance.
|
1.) - "hung" to his chest. The mashed potatoes comparison is a good attempt, but its kind of a long-winded sentence because of it. Maybe see if you can condense it, but keep the comparison.
2.) - The sentence about the fart just doesn't sound intelligent. I would take it out completely.
3.) - I was hoping that the sentece would finish that Matsuda didn't think any man should have to live so long and finish it out in prison, something to make him more human, give him feelings.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
Suddenly one of the younger inmates got up and grabbed the food from the old man’s tray and stuffed it into his own mouth. Two of his larger friends stood up as well, cutting off the old man’s exits, forcing confrontation.
|
No offense, but this is the classic "bully" confrontation. I've seen hundreds of times in prison movies, after school specials, etc,. I know that I've seen it happen in like 5 Steven Segal movies. I'm not sure what you could do to change it, but maybe give it some thought.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
The young guy pushed him, the old fart went backwards but somehow managed to stay upright.
|
By calling the old man an "old fart", you give the narrator an opinion (I know you have the prisoner as the narrator, but...) and can make the narrator unreliable. Plus, Matsuda has just observed the situation and is obviously going to get involved, so why would he refer to the man in a negative way? A simple "old man" would do.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
the newbies always have something to prove, trying to grind their place in the pecking order.
|
I'm not sure that "newbie" is a prison term. More akin to online gaming than anything I think. Pick something else. A little research about prison could go a long way.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
The dumb shit, apparently named Tom, ignored him. I studied the three men, Tom was a pretty scrawny little bastard...
|
Again, the overuse of curse words. Just read it aloud and see how it sounds. Anyone can write those words, try to expand your vocabulary a bit.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
When I was younger and living with my gang, we would often get into street fights. That’s the best way to learn to fight, really.
|
This just sounding stupid to me. It sounded like something that an 8th grader says to a 2nd grader to impress them. Maybe make a reference to the past, but in a less meatheaded way.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
“Back off, you micro!”
|
I like the insult of "micro". It emphasizes Matsuda's size and also kind of gives a unique language to the future. I've never really heard the term before as an insult. New slang is invented all the time and this sounds like something that they use and it separates your sci-fi world from ours, which is very important in sci-fi/fantasy (and even harder in sci-fi I think).
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
We came to the warden’s office, I was brought in first.
|
I wouldn't think that a fight like the one Matsuda had would be enough to go see the warden. I would think he would probably just be detained for awhile a cast back in his cell. I know that you have to further the story and that involves getting into the warden's office, but I think something a little more dire should happen to result in seeing the warden.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
He shook his head, his jowls jiggled so ludicrously that it removed any vague sense of a threatening demeanor that there might have been when he was younger.
|
Very nice visual as well as a insight into the warden's character.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Anguirus2005
"God damn...hell...fuck...Fuck you Matsuda...too fucking late..."
|
See what I mean, kind of an overuse, ya' know? I'm sure the warden is an intelligent enough person to use better words to express himself.
Overall, I thought it was written well enough to keep a person reading. Nothing so far gave it a sci-fi feel though. Maybe describe the guards and their equipment more and have them wearing or weilding futuristic weaponry/armor. Maybe think about how a prison might run in the future. Maybe the prisoners all wear certain collars or restraint devices. Even little things, maybe observations within the warden's office that hint at the future like computers, holograms, etc,.
That's about all I could think of after the first read, so if you post again I'll be sure to follow-up on it.